
Synopsis – A mysterious young man from a New York publisher is sent to Switzerland to persuade the renowned writer Patricia Highsmith to write one final installment of the Ripley anthology.
My Take – Despite her passing in 1995, Patricia Highsmith continues to remain one of the most influential psychological thriller writers of the 20th century. Renowned for her unnerving explorations of obsession, deception, identity, and the darker impulses of human nature, she rarely dealt in traditional heroes and villains. Instead, her fiction immersed readers in the minds of morally ambiguous, deeply disturbed characters.
Her most enduring creation is undoubtedly Tom Ripley, the charismatic, manipulative, and thoroughly amoral antihero who anchors her acclaimed five-novel series: The Talented Mr. Ripley (1955), Ripley Under Ground (1970), Ripley’s Game (1974), The Boy Who Followed Ripley (1980), and Ripley Under Water (1991). Few literary figures have sustained such fascination, or inspired such unease, across decades of storytelling.
In his first narrative feature since Life (2015), director Anton Corbijn does more than resurrect Ripley. He introduces a fictionalized version of Highsmith herself and places her at the center of a psychological thriller framed through the conventions of a whodunit. Adapted from Joanna Murray-Smith‘s 2014 play Switzerland, the film blurs the boundaries between fiction and reality, weaving a metatextual narrative that borrows the intrigue of a murder mystery without fully embracing the genre. Director Corbijn also in brings considerable style to the material, ensuring the film never feels constrained by its theatrical origins.
Yet for all its atmosphere and ambition, it never quite becomes the fiendishly clever thriller it aspires to be. The sparring conversations between its two protagonists prove far more engaging than the fictional novel they construct together, while a central twist reveals itself long before the film intends. Despite grappling with themes of authorship, identity, and creation, the narrative remains frustratingly elusive, withholding so much information that its emotional and thematic impact often feels diluted.
Still, there is plenty here to admire, particularly in the central performances. Helen Mirren and Alden Ehrenreich clearly relish the material, bringing a magnetic tension to every exchange and allowing the film to burrow under the viewer’s skin. Ehrenreich, in particular, makes a compelling case for himself as Tom Ripley, suggesting he could carry a future adaptation of the novels with ease. Supported by an unsettling score, breathtaking Swiss landscapes, and elegantly appointed interiors, the film cultivates a seductive atmosphere that remains captivating even when the storytelling falls short.

The story follows Edward (Alden Ehrenreich), an ambitious young editor dispatched from New York to the Swiss countryside with a seemingly impossible assignment: convince the reclusive Patricia Highsmith (Helen Mirren) to write one final novel. More specifically, his publishers want another Tom Ripley adventure, hoping to revive the character that made her famous.
Armed with admiration for both the author and her work, Edward believes he can charm Highsmith into returning to the typewriter. Highsmith, however, has little patience for corporate demands or eager young intermediaries. Sharp-tongued, combative, and determined to remain in control, she subjects Edward to a series of psychological games before offering him a challenge: help her devise the perfect murder for a new Ripley novel, and she may consider bringing her iconic antihero back.
As the two begin constructing the story together, Edward becomes involved with the enigmatic Clementine Balfour (Olivia Cooke), a wealthy heiress whose presence further complicates matters. As Edward and Clementine grow closer and Highsmith’s behavior becomes increasingly manipulative, the boundaries between fiction and reality begin to erode.
The bulk of the narrative unfolds as a tense two-hander between Highsmith and Edward, and that’s where the film is at its strongest. On paper, this could easily have been a conventional mystery thriller about an eccentric aging author and an overeager young visitor. The marketing certainly suggests something closer to a lightweight, bargain-bin Knives Out.
To its credit, however, the film aims for something more sophisticated, blending sharp wit, dark humor, and psychological intrigue into a story that remains difficult to pin down. Without giving away its destination, the narrative consistently sidesteps expectations, making its final revelations more intriguing than the familiar setup initially suggests.
That ambition, however, comes with drawbacks. While the film asks viewers to actively piece together the truth, it often mistakes ambiguity for depth, leaving key questions frustratingly unresolved. The line between productive uncertainty and narrative vagueness is a thin one, and it doesn’t always walk it successfully. One of the film’s most promising ideas is the notion of Highsmith and Edward collaboratively constructing a murder plot, with the boundaries between fiction and reality gradually dissolving.
Yet the concept never feels as fully realized as it could. The scenes devoted to crafting the story lack the intellectual sparring and creative friction needed to make the process truly compelling, while the fictional narrative they’re building feels surprisingly generic for something associated with Highsmith’s name. Too often, the film disappears into this invented world for extended stretches without sufficient dramatic stakes, when the far more interesting story is the one unfolding between its protagonists.

The characterization of Highsmith herself is among the film’s boldest choices. Far from presenting her as a lovable literary eccentric, the screenplay embraces her as an often unpleasant and deeply flawed figure. She hurls racist and antisemitic remarks with casual cruelty, reflecting the prejudices that have been well documented in accounts of the author’s real life.
Here, director Anton Corbijn brings a polished visual sensibility to the material, but rarely transforms Highsmith’s Swiss home into a character in its own right. Despite its collection of memorabilia, looming interiors, and carefully displayed weapons, the setting never develops the atmosphere or sense of menace the premise demands. Given the story’s confined setting and theatrical origins, the adaptation occasionally struggles to escape its stage-play roots. Even the pacing occasionally suffers, with certain exchanges circling the same ideas and some stretches feeling repetitive.
Performance wise, bringing Patricia Highsmith to life is no easy task, but Helen Mirren is superb, sinking her teeth into the role with intelligence, wit, and commanding presence. As expected from an actor of her caliber, she captures both Highsmith‘s sharp intellect and deeply abrasive nature without ever softening her edges.
Matching her beat for beat is Alden Ehrenreich, who impressively navigates the duality at the heart of the film. As Edward Ridgeway and the increasingly Ripley-esque persona that emerges throughout the story, Ehrenreich delivers a nuanced performance that gradually blurs the line between the two identities. Much like the best Clark Kent & Superman portrayals, he shifts seamlessly between vulnerability and confidence, making the transformation feel both subtle and convincing.
Olivia Cooke adds an alluring, enigmatic presence as Clementine, injecting the film with charm and seductive poise whenever she appears. Meanwhile, Juliet Stevenson makes the most of her limited screen time, providing strong support to an already excellent ensemble. On the whole, ‘A Talent for Murder‘ is a stylish, uneven thriller whose intriguing concepts and excellent central performances outweigh its narrative shortcomings.
![]()
Directed – Anton Corbijn
Starring – Helen Mirren, Olivia Cooke, Alden Ehrenreich
Rated – R
Run Time – 105 minutes
