
Synopsis – Rick, a washed-up wedding singer, and Danny, a fading boy band star, bond over music and a late-night jam session. When Danny turns Rick’s song into a hit, Rick sets out to reclaim the recognition he believes he deserves.
My Take – Indeed, John Carney remains one of the most reliable filmmakers working today. His films have never missed the mark, consistently delivering unforgettable music, tender love stories, and a generous dose of humor.
Once (2007) captured raw intimacy through song, Begin Again (2013) expanded that magic into a soulful New York tale, Sing Street (2016) bottled youthful rebellion and joy, and Flora and Son (2023) reaffirmed music’s power to heal fractured lives. Across these works, the Irish writer-director has shown an unmatched gift for weaving melodies into lifelines, making his cinema deeply resonant.
Unsurprisingly, his latest effort follows suit, though with a slightly different rhythm. While music remains central, Carney and co-writer Peter McDonald (who also shines in a supporting role as Rick’s best friend Sandy) craft a smart, convincing exploration of how men grapple with success, failure, and the blurred lines of creative ownership.
And as a crowd‑pleaser, the result film is a genuine triumph. The comedy flows effortlessly, the emotional beats resonate with precision, and the narrative moves with a quiet assurance rather than a need for validation. It’s witty, heartfelt, and irresistibly charming—never tipping into manipulation.
Sure, it may not reach the soulfulness or exuberance of his earlier films, but anchored by two witty, surprisingly layered performances from Paul Rudd and Nick Jonas, it deserves praise for its honest look at middle-age despair, youthful insecurities, and thwarted ambitions. Director Carney’s bar is high, which makes this feel like a modest step down, yet there’s still so much to enjoy that fans will leave satisfied and uplifted.

The story follows Rick Power (Paul Rudd), the American frontman of a Dublin wedding band, The Bride and Groove. Once chasing dreams of stardom, Rick settled into family life after marrying his Irish girlfriend Rachel (Marcella Plunkett) and raising their daughter Aja (Beth Fallon). These days, he mostly plays covers, occasionally slipping in his own songs that dampen the party mood.
At a castle wedding, the band crosses paths with Danny Wilson (Nick Jonas), a washed‑up former boy‑band star and friend of the groom. And when Danny joins Rick on stage for a spirited duet of Stevie Wonder’s I Wish, sparks fly. Later, Danny invites Rick to his hotel room—a makeshift studio crammed with instruments and recording gear—where he reveals plans for a solo comeback.
The two spend the night drinking, smoking, and sharing music, with Rick performing his original track, How to Write a Song (Without You). Though Danny departs with a generous gift, his promise of future collaboration feels hollow. Back in Los Angeles, Danny’s manager Mac (Jack Reynor) dismisses his new material.
Urged on by his girlfriend Marcia (Havana Rose Liu), Danny records Rick’s song instead. Six months later, Rick hears his tune, now transformed into a glossy, over‑produced anthem, blaring through a Dublin shopping center. Craving recognition, he becomes consumed by the theft, straining his band and family ties. Meanwhile, Danny rides the wave of success: 100 million views, a sold‑out arena tour, and a revitalized career.
What begins as a seemingly straightforward story of artistic ownership gradually unfolds into something far more intimate and affecting. At its core, the film is about ambition and the dream of “making it,” the fantasy every busker clings to of one day becoming a star.
Yet, as is often the case with director Carney, the real subject lies elsewhere: the cruel binary of success and failure. For every artist who ascends, there’s a shadow army of those left behind like friends, collaborators, hometown hopefuls—forced to wrestle with the lifelong ache of not making it.

Here, director Carney and co-writer Peter McDonald wisely builds the narrative not on escalating conflict but on emotional generosity. No one here is a villain. Instead, each character is flawed, insecure, desperate to matter, and searching for validation in their own way. That tenderness toward human weakness is precisely what makes director Carney’s films resonate so deeply. There are also flashes of sheer craftsmanship that elevate the film.
One standout sequence cross‑cuts between Danny electrifying a stadium crowd and Rick playing to a handful of patrons in a dingy rural pub. The juxtaposition captures everything the film wants to say about fame, visibility, ambition, and ownership, that too without a single line of exposition.
And then there’s the music. Unsurprisingly, it’s superb. Director Carney once again proves his uncanny ability to make songs feel inseparable from character emotion rather than tacked‑on soundtrack filler. These tracks are lived‑in, messy, and achingly honest. They pulse with yearning. I already find myself waiting impatiently for the soundtrack release, eager to loop these songs endlessly and sink back into that emotional groove.
Performance wise, Paul Rudd brings his trademark likability, the kind that makes audiences instinctively root for him. What’s refreshing here is seeing the eternally youthful Rudd lean into crumpled middle age, smoking, swearing, and watching his lifelong dream curdle into a nightmare. There’s a quiet ache beneath his performance that he plays with remarkable restraint, and he proves surprisingly convincing behind the mic as well.
Opposite him, Nick Jonas delivers a strong turn. His musical chops are a given, and playing a boy‑band alumnus is second nature, but Danny could easily have slipped into caricature. Jonas avoids that trap, finding sympathy in a character whose actions are often despicable. Their chemistry is one of the film’s strongest assets: Jonas captures the insecurity beneath Danny’s polished exterior, though the heavier emotional beats ultimately belong to Rudd.
In supporting roles, Peter McDonald, Marcella Plunkett, Beth Fallon, and Havana Rose Liu all contribute memorable moments, while Carney regular Jack Reynor steals scenes as Danny’s sleazy manager, dismissing Rick as just another hanger‑on trying to bleed his client dry. On the whole, ‘Power Ballad‘ stands as a crowd‑pleasing musical comedy, consistently landing as a soulful ode to dreamers, heartbreak, and the songs that keep us alive.
![]()
Directed – John Carney
Starring – Paul Rudd, Nick Jonas, Havana Rose Liu
Rated – R
Run Time – 98 minutes
